The formula
Cost per lead is what a vendor quotes you. Cost per signed case is what you actually pay to add a client, and it is the only number worth comparing across vendors:
Cost per signed case = cost per lead ÷ sign rate.
Sign rate is the share of leads your firm turns into signed retainers. It depends on lead quality, but it depends just as much on your intake: how fast you call, how often you follow up and whether someone answers at 10pm on a Saturday.
- $250 lead at 15% sign rate = $1,667 per signed case
- $300 lead at 10% sign rate = $3,000 per signed case
- $350 lead at 7% sign rate = $5,000 per signed case
- A $150 shared lead at 3% sign rate = $5,000 per signed case
How many leads does it take to sign one case?
Divide 100 by your sign rate. At 10% you need 10 leads per case; at 15%, about 7. Firms buying shared or aged leads often sign 2% to 5%, which means 20 to 50 leads per case and a cheap lead that turns into an expensive case.
If you don't know your sign rate, work it out from the last 90 days before you buy anything: signed retainers from paid leads divided by paid leads received. Our pricing calculator runs the same math on per-lead prices for your state.
Costs the lead price leaves out
The formula above only counts what you paid the vendor. Your real cost per case also includes the intake staff who work the leads, the CRM and phone tools, and the leads that sign and then turn out to be weak cases. A firm paying intake staff to dial 10 leads per signed case should add that labor to the number.
When signed cases are the cheaper option
A signed case has a fixed price: the claimant has already signed your retainer, so there is no sign rate to estimate and no intake labor to add. That makes the comparison simple. Work out your real cost per signed case from leads, including intake, and compare it with the per-case price.
Signed cases tend to win when your sign rate is low, when you have no 24/7 intake, or when you are entering a new state and don't have a feel for conversion there yet. Exclusive MVA leads tend to win when your intake team is fast and signs well above 10%. Many firms use both: leads where their intake is strong, signed cases where it isn't. A good signed-case program also lets you reject cases you don't want; ours gives you 30 days from receiving the signed retainer, and replaces rejected cases.
Track the number every month
- Leads received and signed retainers by source, every month.
- Spend by source, including any monthly fees.
- Cost per signed case by source: spend divided by signed retainers.
- Cases dropped after signing, so a cheap source that signs weak cases doesn't look better than it is.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you calculate cost per signed case?
Divide your cost per lead by your sign rate. A $300 lead with a 10% sign rate costs $3,000 per signed case. For a fuller number, add intake labor and tools to the lead spend before dividing by signed retainers.
How many leads does a law firm need to sign one case?
Divide 100 by the firm's sign rate. At a 10% sign rate it takes 10 leads per signed case; at 15%, about 7. Shared and aged leads often sign at 2% to 5%, which means 20 to 50 leads per case.
Is cost per lead or cost per signed case more important?
Cost per signed case. A cheap lead that rarely signs costs more per client than an expensive lead that signs often. Compare vendors on cost per signed case from your own intake data.
When is buying signed cases cheaper than buying leads?
When your real cost per signed case from leads, including intake labor, is higher than the per-case price of a signed-case program. That is most common for firms with low sign rates, no 24/7 intake, or a new state.
